he debate over whether the NFL should ban the “Tush Push” (or Brotherly Shove, as it’s been called when the Eagles run it) is a hot topic. Here are a few reason to why the NFL should ban it and a few reasons to why they probably won’t. What are your thoughts?
Why the NFL Might Ban It
1. Injury Concerns – Some worry that the play creates unnecessary injury risks, particularly for linemen and defenders trying to stop a mass of bodies. While data hasn’t shown a significant increase in injuries yet, the league tends to err on the side of caution.
2. Unfair Advantage – Critics argue that the play is nearly unstoppable, especially with teams like the Eagles perfecting it. They say it eliminates defensive skill and turns short-yardage situations into automatic conversions.
3. Aesthetic/Entertainment Factor – The NFL wants exciting plays. Some believe the Tush Push is too mechanical and reduces dramatic moments, like a traditional QB sneak or a big fourth-down stop.
Why the NFL Should Keep It
1. It’s Not Actually Unstoppable – While the Eagles have mastered it, other teams have struggled. If it were truly unfair, every team would be running it at a high success rate.
2. It’s a Smart Football Play – The play is based on execution, strength, and strategy. Banning it would feel like punishing a team for being better prepared.
3. There’s No Clear Safety Issue – Unlike previous banned plays (e.g., wedge blocks on kickoffs), there’s no overwhelming evidence that this play is leading to more injuries.
Unless there’s a major injury trend, banning the Tush Push would feel like an overreaction. If defenses want to stop it, they need to adjust. Instead of changing the rules, the NFL should let teams figure out counter-strategies. Personally I always thought you were not allowed to push or carry guys forward, but like offensive interference, it hardly ever gets called!!
